Recently, we have scolded the New York Yankees for giving too much to the Boston Red Sox. In recent years, Brian Cashman has gladly delivered them bullpen weapons (Garrett Whitlock, the rising Greg Weissert), a rotation component (Richard Fitts), and a possible starting catcher (Carlos Narvaez) because he is no longer scared to deal with his main opponent.

However, it’s difficult to blame the Yankees for their subtly made roster change on Sunday, which gave Boston another possible way to get rid of them.

There was nothing New York could have done to respect Dominic Smith’s desires and maintain the strength of their own big-league squad when faced with an opt-out provision. Smith’s Triple- Ironically, a run in May came as the Red Sox were scrambling to replace temporary first baseman after stopgap first baseman and lost Triston Casas for the season. Ironically, the first Yankees and Red Sox series of the season, which will take place in the Bronx next weekend, fell on the last day of May. Both of these facts are not really welcome for the Yankees, who may have to deal with irate fans in June (what else is new?) if Boston decides to buy the Yankees lunch in the hopes that Smith’s power output will keep increasing.

In addition to the fact that Giancarlo Stanton’s eventual return will likely upset many with or without Smith, adding Smith to the MLB roster would have either resulted in the demotion of Ben Rice or a loss of infield versatility at second and third base (especially with Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s return imminent). The veteran first baseman would have likely lost his roster spot regardless.

Following his minor-league opt-out, the Yankees have offered the Red Sox an opportunity to re-sign first baseman Dominic Smith.
It wouldn’t have made sense to bring Smith to the bigs in New York unless the Yankees were determined to do everything it took to keep him out of Boston’s clutches. That’s very poor business, considering the Yankees’ current circumstances.

However, we all know that Smith would instantly replace Abraham Toro as the Yankees’ greatest danger in their current lineup if the Sox make the move. Boston usually uses the most unexpected bat to burn the Yankees. Add in the “revenge factor” (revenge for what, precisely, giving him the freedom he begged for?), and it’s a wrap.

However, there was nothing the Yankees could have done. All they can do is hope that Boston favors Romy Gonzalez, Kristian Campbell, Nate Eaton, and the rare out-of-position game from Roman Anthony.